Announcement

  • Congratulations!! Team Sky, Team Air & Team Fire Qualified for Semifinal Round.

QUARTER FINAL | BUSINESS CASE - BCS 04

Finance Manager Submission BCS 04

NMO 2020

Budget for FY'19-20 and Financial Plan

Submission Date & Time : 2020-03-23 07:31:16

Submitted By: Naseef nazar Nalakath - Finance Manager From Team Sky

Case UnderstandingDaily Needs Delivery LLP(DND) is a Start-up that was founded by Sam Malhotra & Rajish Gupta in 2017. It had a 15-lakh seed capital put in by the founders. It uses an app-based ordering system and deals in dairy products mainly milk, paneer and curd. The customers can order using the app and the product gets delivered to their homes. DND Currently operates in 3 cities, Bengaluru, Delhi & Hyderabad. Problems related to finance- Operating profit (i.e. Total sales > Total Cost of procurement) but net loss (total sales < total loss). Loss= 68 lakhs High cost for advertisement (2L/month). This might be due to TV advertisements which are costly. The corporate employee is hired at 50000/ month. Hence the productivity is expected to go up from their side. The Company is unable to generate profit even after operating in dense areas (cities). The cost will only increase in non-dense areas (due to transportation, reach, etc) and hence the company will incur more losses while expanding. Less expense on IT front. One example of this is people unable to find Email-id to register complaint.
BCS Solution Summary(i) Budget The budget has been prepared conservatively. The profit per product is assumed to be same while sales projections are made from the previous data of 2 years.. It focuses on strengthening the current customer base and increasing the reach within the 3 initial cities. The company incurred a loss of 68L in the previous year. This year, with proper planning and budgeting, we expect to make a net profit of 15 L (approx.). The budget does cost-cutting by reducing expenses for marketing while the Information technology infrastructure is developed with a budget of 3L. Please refer to the attached pdf for detailed report of budget and financial plan.
Solution

(i) The assumption and calculations used while preparing budget are:-

The previous year growth in sales was 74.7% (from ’17-18 to ’18-19), which is roughly equal to 4.7% growth per month. For the next financial year, we assume a growth rate of 6% due to the revamped marketing techniques, new HR solutions, Latest IT infrastructure and stability obtained from the past 2 years of experience.

The profit margin per product is assumed to be the same as the previous year. That is no change in cost of procurement. This is a conservative estimate and it ignores the cost reductions due to increase in purchases (or sales). This means that bulk discounts which could be obtained from the vendors are ignored to prepare a conservative budget. However, from historical data, products such as milk have always had low profit margins and it is difficult to cut the cost of procurement. Eg; Amul ( found in 1946) has a total profit of only 6 million while the revenue was 2 Billion (all in US dollars and data from 2012-13 Amuls’ income statement) Note: currently, profit margin for DND is 11%. Hence cost is assumed to be 89% of the revenue.

IT: For converting the cost for IT infrastructure such as SAP business one ERP and Tableau subscription we have used 75.62 as the conversion rate of dollar to rupees.

IT: The SAP business one ERP is used by 2 corporate employees if the IT dept. At this stage of the company, 2 dashboards are sufficient. Note that one Tableau subscription is also used for better planning and growth. The total expense for IT is 3.3L/year.

HR: Since the sales are increasing, we are planning to hire 4 delivery boys every month. Also 3 more corporate employees will be hired after 6 months to account for the growth. This means that by the year end, the company will have 128 delivery boys and 13 corporate staffs. This will be enough since various HR training techniques (under HR costs in Budget) will increase productivity per employee. Also, the salaries are kept the same as the previous year.

Marketing: To overcome the high expense in marketing, we are using Digital tools such as SEOs and Social media, as these are cheap and effective at the same time. We will also employ OOHs which are relatively cheaper to reduce the expense for advertising. We believe that for this year, we will be targeting upper middle class in Tier-1 cities and hence such type of advertising will have maximum impact. From the coming years we will start using newspaper and TV ads, while we will be expanding to Tier1 and Tier-2 cities. The total marketing expense for the year is 2L

Other overheads: This was 3L/month in the previous year. Conservatively, we assume an increase of 4%/month for this expense.

Other points:-

The total sales for the year is 17.50 crores.

The net profit (after accounting for all costs) is 15L.

The total cost is 17.35 crores. This is divided into 15.5 crores (cost of procurement)+ 1.68 crores (salary)+ 0.46 (crores)

(ii) The financial plan (attached) is a projection of sales and net income for the coming 5 fiscal years. Here we can see that net income increases by 49 % each year. This prediction is made on the consideration that a larger customer base in dense tier 1 cities for the next 5 years will ensure high profitability. After this time period, profit might fluctuate due to expansion plans into Tier-2 and tier-3 cities, other products effect (now we assume that milk is our primary product), and backward integration.

 

The attached PDFs are;

1)      Budget for the next fiscal year

2)      The financial plan (income projections) for the next 5 years

Optional Assignment
ConclusionThe company is expected to grow at a rate of 49% for the next 5 years. A net income of 15L is expected to be made for the first year (FY’19-20) from a Net loss of 68 L in the previous year (FY’18-19). The budget has been prepared conservatively while income and revenue generation are assumed to have a steady growth (49%) for the next 5 years.
Attached File Details

Comments

me

Rajni Khosala

A well planned effort towards bringing firm to the positive !

me

Sandeep Bhatt

Case is studied in a details manner, Budgeting is done considering all departments. As a finance leader planning for fund is very important in a new startup which is in constant loss and have potential to expand.





Participant

Naseef nazar Nalakath

IIM INDORE

Naseef Nazar is an MBA student in Indian Institute of Management Indore (IIMI).
He has cleared Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) Level One in first attempt.
He is also certified in NISM Investment Advisor Level 1 with a score of 81.5% and NISM Research Analyst with a score of 92.5%.
He is passionate about banking and finance.
Well aware of the market trends, he is an active learner and dedicated student.