Announcement

  • Congratulations!! Team Sky, Team Air & Team Fire Qualified for Semifinal Round.

QUARTER FINAL | BUSINESS CASE - BCS 04

Marketing Manager Submission BCS 04

NMO 2020

DND CASE ANALYSIS - MARKETING DEPARTMENT

Submission Date & Time : 2020-03-22 06:52:09

Submitted By: N Praveen Ram - Marketing Manager From Team Sky

Case UnderstandingThe case talks about a newly found online grocery items delivery company DND, which finds its itself on the backfoot. This is attributed to the poor and improper sales and distribution efforts of the company. The sales personnel who lacked motivation resulting in the wrong, misplaced or incomplete delivery of products to the customer and finally bad reviews and customer testimonials. The company currently has its operations in Delhi, Bangalore and Hyderabad in partnership with a hyperlocal delivery firm for the delivery of orders. Though the company wants to have a wide range of grocery items in its delivery portfolio, it currently delivers only milk and its derivative products.
BCS Solution SummaryThe solution aims to analyze and come up with an appropriate solution for the problem the company currently faces. The solution talks about the incorrect positioning of the company in the minds of the customer and how the company has targeted the wrong customer segment. The marketing plan for the next financial year is also developed along with a expected reach of the app over the next 10 years.
Solution

. The problems marketing faced by the sales and the marketing department of the company:

Problems face by the sales force:

  • Customer complaints of non-delivery of ordered products.
  • Improper delivery of products- delivery of wrong products.
  • Delivery of stale products.
  • Incomplete delivery- missing products that have been ordered but not delivered.
  • Delivery personnel not showing up for duty.
  • Loss of inventory due to the perishable nature of the products.

Solutions:

The sales force is the key to the profitability of the firm. Since, the entire business of the firm is dependent on the timely and correct delivery of the ordered products, it is imperative for the sales force to be at its best. Only a well-motivated sales force can ensure the sustained competitive advantage for the firm on the long run.

Therefore, the management of DND has to:

  • Incentivize the delivery personnel. This can be in the form of monetary benefits like bonus for surpassing sales targets apart from the regular salary or it can be other benefits like medical insurance for the delivery person and one his/her family member or vehicle maintenance for the delivery person and so on. These initiatives on the company’s behalf will motivate the delivery personnel and would reduce the problem of absenteeism significantly.
  • Training the sales force on the correct delivery of the products. Extreme care has to be taken when it comes to packaging the exact goods required by the customer. Since, this is a new company even a small mistake blows out of proportion and hurts the future prospects of the company.
  • DND must also maintain a healthy relationship with its suppliers. Being a new player in the market, it has to foster a productive relationship with these suppliers who are major players in the market and who supply in huge volumes to the well-established grocery chains in the country. Only then, DND will have an influencing hand in the bargaining and negotiations process when it aims to expand its business in the later years, both product wise and geographically.
  • All the people involved in ensuring that the order reaches the customer’s doorstep need to be in line with the company’s mission and vision. They need to have a feeling of being part of something new and good. This thought process in the minds of the sales force would be a driver for them to show up for work every day, work with passion and focus. Nurturing, such a sense of ownership will be a much stronger motivating factor than monetary benefits that they are entitled to.
  • The company should also maintain only the necessary amount of inventory required or face loss of products due to the perishable nature of the products sold.
  • In order to give a more wholesome buying experience from DND, the company has to come up with an omnichannel communications system. This system would ensure constant engagement with the customer and would ensure the quick redressal of any order or delivery related problems the customer is facing. This conversation with customer will give the company the much-needed firsthand information about the company’s performance and the adequacy in the level of customer centricity the company currently maintains.
  • Another step that the company can take in ensuring lesser complications at the time of delivery is to use sophisticated tools like customer product code (CPC) and standardize the products delivered. Once, the product is standardized, it will be much easier for the delivery person to deliver the right goods to the customer.

Problems faced by the marketing department:

  • Positioning- DND positioned itself as a deliverer of daily household groceries. The company started out with delivering milk and its derivative products. Though they had sophisticated mobile applications that customers could use and a sales force that could deliver those orders, the company however couldn’t find traction. This can be possibly attributed to the comparison of this company’s services with those of the regular milk vendors who have been serving people for years. This, along with delivery issues added to the company’s woes.
  • Targeting- DND targeted a very general population with no special focus on a particular segment of customers. The exclusivity that the company wanted their customers to enjoy, was lost because many people were being targeted.

Solutions:

  • The company should position itself as a “premium provider of home delivery service of groceries” at least for the initial years before it moves down market. The company must be re-orient itself as a competitor for the well-established companies in the grocery home delivery market space. It should be seen as an alternative for established players like Grofers, Big Basket, Amazon etc. rather than as an alternative to the local milk vendors. It is this high-end image and exclusivity that can save the company from its current turmoil.

In order to have the above-mentioned image and mind share among the customer’s, DND has to target the right customers. The service provided by DND is ideally suited for the “urban upper middle-class households” where both the husband and the wife go to work. Their day ends somewhere around six or seven in the evening and they visit the groceries on their way home, in order to have the essential items for the next day. Since, DND is currently operating in the well-developed cities of Hyderabad, Bengaluru and Delhi where people are more open to the startup culture and are willing to try services from new players, targeting the above-mentioned customer group would give the company the right kind of recognition it needed. DND can also price the products slightly above those of the brick and mortar stores because these customers are not that price sensitive as long as their energy is being saved

Revenue generation expected in a month:

 Assuming order of:

 2 one litre milk packet = 2*50 = Rs.100

 1 500gm paneer            = 1*150 = Rs.150

 1 250gm curd                = 1*40   = Rs.40

 Total                                            = Rs.290 per order

Categorizing customers into three types: Platinum- 6 orders per week

                                                                  Gold      - 4 orders per week

                                                                  Silver     - 2 orders per week

Given 6500 people currently use the app: We can assume- Platinum: 50 people

                                                                                              Gold:        250 people

                                                                                               Silver:    6200 people

Therefore, the total revenue generation per month: Rs.1,58,92,000

Year

Expected Reach

0

6500

1

8000

2

10000

3

12000

4

15000

5

20000

6

40000

7

60000

8

100000

9

125000

10

500000

 

MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES USED TO DEVELOP THE SOLUTION:

  1. Positioning
  2. Segmentation
  3. Sales force management
  4. Integrated marketing communications
  5. Customer relationship management

Optional Assignment
ConclusionCONCLUSION: With the given solutions DND must be able to save its falling reputation as a first step. Then with the base of existing customers, it must be in a position to expand both geographically and product-wise over the following years as it builds it customer base and customer satisfaction through a much improved sales force and delivery systems in place backed by a strong communication channel with the customer in addressing any queries and problems faced by the customer. The expansion into other areas and improvement of performance is made possible through standardization of the product offerings across regions of distribution. Standardization results in lesser complications in delivering the correct product to the customer’s doorstep. Also, the company has to improve its inventory management as storage of products for prolonged periods of time is not feasible due to the perishable nature of goods.
Attached File Details

Comments

me

Winston Pinto

Good understanding of the problem statement and derived solutions. It could be better to understand more on packaging and testing product shelf life. Solution to complaints of non delivery not addressed. Presentation could be better if there was more details on Marketing strategies to be implemented now and in the future.

me

Shruti bhargav

Understanding problem is the key, knowing the product defines its way of marketing. Both needs to be taken care of.





Participant

N Praveen Ram

Great Lakes Institute of Management

1st year b-school student